[Date Prev][Date Next][Thread Prev][Thread Next][Date Index][Thread Index]
Re:Edamame
Re: Edamame
It's true that tofu varieties can be used for edamame. We understand
that China exports large amounts of frozen edamame that are hand picked
from fields of tofu variety beans. Varieties grown in the the north like
Vinton 81 are indeterminate and have beans in all stages of maturity on
the stalk at the same time. You have a real advantage if they mature
uniformly where you live. We understand that edamame varieties are
determinate, giving a more concentrated harvest. Hand picking edamame is
only possible in a place like China where there is a large very low paid
labor supply.
Varieties like Butterbean have been around for a long time, more than 30
years, and are usually sold as vegetable soybeans - they do not make good
'grain' type soybeans. They are low yielders and their pods tend to
dehisce, or split open, when mature - this makes harvesting dry soybeans
for feed/food or for seed very difficult. Butterbeans are reputed to
have a somewhat better flavor when green, certainly a different, less
starchy flavor with a higher sugar content. Butterbean seed is available
from a number of American seed companies, such as Johnny's. There are
new varieties that have been developed primarily in Japan that may have
better quality, at least to the Asian palate. The best varieties have
silver pubescence (hairs) on the pods and an even higher sugar content
than Butterbean. We've been told that these newer varieties dehisce even
more than Butterbeans, making them very difficult to produce seed from.
Consequently, the seed prices are quite high. Seed from these newer
varieties is imported from Japan and the varieties are patented. We
understand there are edamame varieties that are better adapted to the
southern/mid Atlantic US, but we are not familiar with them. There's a
large edamame industry in Taiwan for processing, they must have varieties
adapted to hotter climates, but initial seed would be very expensive.
The Japanese are reported to plant edamame soybeans at lower field
populations than we would ordinarily plant soybeans in the US. This
allows better sunlight penetration to lower pods. Highest yields in
American research are at 80 lb/seed per acre. We don't personally have
enough experience to know what yield to expect from that seeding rate -
we have just recently researched this information, looking at edamame as
a possible processing vegetable. There are a couple of brands of frozen
edamame available in the US, Snopac and Cascadian both market frozen
edamame and they are really quite good to eat . The frozen edamame
tasted much better than our own Vintons tasted when we tried cooking them
young and in the pods, but we think the edamame were harvested younger
than we harvested the Vintons - they seem much like lima beans that way,
when young they have a sweet, crisp, non-starchy flavor (what they call
lima beans fixed this way 'butterbeans' in North Carolina!), but when
older, the starch flavor predominates. We really don't know what
constitutes good edamame flavor though. However, if your customers like
the flavor of Vinton picked as edamame and if your Vintons act as
determinate plants (unlike in the north), you are fortunate - your seed
cost will be less and your yields may be higher.
There are several good resources available for more information on
edamame. First, Dr. Carol Miles at Washington State University has been
doing quite a lot of work on these and other Asian vegetables in a
northern region. Since soybeans are highly day length sensitive, this
may not be of as much value to growers further south, but could be a
starting place. She has an extensive website that lists cultural
information and seed sources. Also, the Asian Vegetable Resource Center
in Taiwan has lots of information on varieties, cultural requirements,
harvesting and marketing. They do not have a website, but can be reached
over email at sundar@Netra.AVRDC.org.tw.
Hope this helps someone out there! Klaas and Mary-Howell Martens
To Unsubscribe: Email majordomo@cals.ncsu.edu with the command
"unsubscribe sanet-mg". If you receive the digest format, use the command
"unsubscribe sanet-mg-digest".
To Subscribe to Digest: Email majordomo@cals.ncsu.edu with the command
"subscribe sanet-mg-digest".
All messages to sanet-mg are archived at:
http://www.sare.org/san/htdocs/hypermail