Subject: opinions re logan or bridgrport

From: tom bean <"[email-masked]"@postoffice.worldnet.att.net>
Date: Thu, 19 Sep 1996 16:09:07 -0500

would like advice on the value of a logan model#825 lathe (10"x30") i'm 
a complete novice without a clue. it is in reasonable condition and 
includes a rest and a small number of tools. would this be a sensible 
lathe to learn with? would a bridgeport of similar size cost as much? 
also, what name brand mill\drill with a single phase motor would be 
worth looking for? thanks for the help.

---

From: [email-masked] (Scott Logan)
Date: 19 Sep 1996 21:49:42 GMT

In article <[email-masked].  net>, From tom 
bean <"[email-masked]"@postoffice.wor  ldnet.att.net>, the
following was written: > would like advice on the value of a logan
model#825 lathe (10"x30")

Tom,

Perhaps others here can give a more objective appraisal of the value of
your Model 825, but I think it's an excellent lathe.  First machine tool
I ever used was an 825 in my Dad's basement, and he still uses it today.
 BTW, it's a 10" x 24". The Model 825 was first developed for the US
Navy for shipboard use, which is why they had 3 feet instead of the
usual 4.  

--
 ----------------------------------------
 Scott Logan [email-masked]
 09/19/96 16:48
 http://www.loganact.com

---

From: [email-masked](Dave Ficken)
Date: 19 Sep 1996 22:37:15 GMT

>worth looking for? thanks for the help.
Tom,
 While Bridgeport has manufactured several types of machines in its
history, they are best known for their Milling machines. When someone
refers to "a Bridgeport", it is generally understood that they are
referring to a Mill. So, a comparison of a Bridgeport and a Logan lathe
is tough to do. 
 Logan Lathes are generally regarded as quality American made machines,
well suited for hobbyists. They carry the added advantage to you of
being able to enter into a dialogue with the manufacturer right here on
RCM (I'm sure Scott Logan will respond to your posting.)
 As for the price, that's not so easilly answered. It really depends on
several factors: your geographic location, condition of the lathe,
amount and quality of accessories. This is a decent machine for a
beginner, and if you don't overpay you will be able to get your money
back when you decide to trade up.
 As for the Best make of Mill/drill, a better question to ask would be:
which supplier of import mill/drills has the best reputation for
standing behind their product? I don't know the answer to that one. It
is best answered by someone who has bought one of these machines.
Regards,
Dave Ficken
Meridian Machinery " A different kind of Machinery Dealer"
http://hre.com/meridian

---

From: "Kevin Rhodes, P.E." <[email-masked]>
Date: Thu, 19 Sep 1996 21:39:28 -0700

> worth looking for? thanks for the help.

I just bought a lathe.  A South Bend 9x36.  I looked at a Logan and would 
have bought it had it been in better condition.

Do yourself a favor.  Get a book out of the library and do some reading. 
 I did and am very glad for it.  It took a lot of the mystery out of it. 
 This newsgroup is also a tremendous help.  I have really appreciated the 
 generous responses to my questions.

Another bit of advice.  Don't buy the first one you find.  At least not 
right away.  You won't have any basis for comparison.  As Dave Ficken 
responded, geography will play into the price.  I am somewhat fortunate 
in that I am near Cincinnati and it's just a machine tool kind of town.  
So there was a fairly good selection.  Good luck.

---

From: [email-masked] (Alan Muller)
Date: 21 Sep 1996 20:37:33 GMT

In article <[email-masked]>, "Kevin Rhodes, P.E." <[email-masked]> says:
>> lathe to learn with?

I have a 10" Logan.  It has been a serviceable machine for me, but if 
I were looking now, I'd hold out for one with a spindle able to
take 5C collets.

am