Sri Parthasarathi thunai
Srimathe ramanujaya Namaha
Srimad Vara Vara munayE Namaha
Sri vAnAchala mahA munayE Namaha
Paasuram-72
"ellara millEl tuRavara millennum
sollaRa mallanavum sollalla-nallaRa
mAvanavum nAlvEdha mAththavamum nAraNanE
yAvadhee tandRenpArAr"
Listening to thirumazhisai piran's complaint about those who haven't learnt the
divine meanings some questioned, "Why do you just talk ill of the ignorant why
shouldn't you, who have learnt the same give it to the world?"
Thirumazhisai piran with all grace gives the meaning of the charama sloka, the
enlightening crux in this paasuram.
Sri Krishna charama sloka is the essence of Mahabharata; Sri Rama charama sloka
is the essence of Sri Ramayana; same is the case with "memporul" paasuram in
thondaradipodi Azhvar's thirumaalai; here this paasuram is the highlight of
nAnmugan thiruvandhAdhi.
(ellaRam ellennum sollum sollalla) Those verses that advocate karma yoga to be
the means to moksha are not pramanas. The word "ellaRam" is equated to karma
yoga as only a gruhastan has the rights to perform yagna, dhana and tapas.
Otherwise the word 'sharaNam' conveys three meanings viz., way, house and
protector. "el" in tamil refers to a house. 'sharaNa' and 'gruha' are
synonyms and hence 'el' is considered to refer to upaya/means over here.
So pravruththi dharma is neglected.
(tuRavaram el ennum sollum sol alla) All those verses that declare jnana yoga
to be the means to moksha are also not to be accepted. Here "turavaram"
indicates jnana yoga, as it has to be performed by sacrificing karma yoga. It
has to be noted that even Sri Krishna in his divine bhagavat geetha refers to
jnana yoga with the word sanyasa "sanyAsam karmanAm" (geetha 5-1) "sanyAsasthu"
(5-6) and so on.
"yadhaidAmsi samithOgnir basmasAth kurutErjuna"
[just like the fire that burns a log of firewood to ashes, properly performed
jnana yoga burns all karmas)
(aramallanavum sollalla) All those verses that state other means to be the
mokshOpaya are also not pramanas
Which are the other dharmas considered to be the mokshopaya?
1) "bhakthyA tvananyayA shakya:" -bhakthi yoga
2) "dEsOyam sarva kAma duk"-DivyadEsa vAsam
3) "kim jabhan muchyatE janthu:"- ThirunAmasankeerthanam
4) "janma karma cha mE divyam" - Avatara rahasya jnanam
5) "yO mAmEvam asammudo jAnAthi purushOtamam"-purushOtama vidya
All these have been repeatedly stated to be the means to moksha in the ithihasa
puranas and bhagavat geetha by the rishis and bhagavan himself. How does
azhvar then without any hesitation disregards these verses? It is due to the
strength given by the geethacharyan to thirumazhisai piran. GeethAcharyan
himself overrides his previous statements with the parama pramana "sarva
dharmAn parityajya" (leave all the (aforeside) dharmas).
Though karma, jnana, bhakthi yogas are considered to be the means still being
insentient these are incapable of granting the results by themselves. The
result has to be given only by the parama chetanan, emperuman Sriman narayanan.
Emperuman doesn't depend on anything for granting the result since he is
sarva shakthan. Thereby the inner deep meanings conveyed in the Vedanta are
explicitly given here by thirumazisai piran in simple lucid words.
If split as "sollara mallana" then we derive the above meaning (pramEya param).
On the contrary if read as "ellennum sol" then the pramEyas karma, jnana and
bhakthi as stated by the pramanas are not the means (pramAna param)
Why are these not considered to be the means?
(nallaRamAvanavum) aram- refers to karma; nallaRam-those duties done without
any expectation. Those that have been specified in the ithihasa puranas viz.,
namasankeerthanam etc.
(nAlvEdha mAththavamum) The duties (karma yoga) specified in the first half
(poorva bhaga) of the Vedas.
(nAraNanEyAvadhu) All the other karmas are effective only due to the divine
grace of the almighty.
How?
For all the other means emperuman is essential to grant the final result
whereas emperuman needs no help to grant moksha.
(Edhu andru enpAr Ar)Who can refute this great fact? Without any dispute the
Vedas, bhagavan Sri Krishna, the vedantins, the rishis and all the azhvars
accept emperuman to be the mokshOpayam.
A few quotes from the words of rishis:
"yamaiovaisha vrunuthE tEna labhya:"
"nyasa iti brahma.nyAsa A-vatyarEchayEt"
"lOkAnAm tvam parO dharma:"
"rAmO vigrahavAn dharma:"
"krishnam dharma sanAtanam"
"pAvanas sarva lOkAnAm tvamEva"
Words of bhagavan
"mAmEkamEva sharanam"
"sharaNam mAm prapadyava"
Words of Azhvars
"aRantAnAi thirivAi"
"nAganai misai nampirAn charanE shaRan namakku"
"kalaikan neeyE"
Charama sloka in this paasuram
"ellaRamillEl tuRavaRamillennum sollaRamallanavum sollalla" - sarva dharmAn
parityajya
"nAraNan"- mAm, aham
"nArananE" - EkAram parallel to Ekam
"nallaRamAvanavum nAlvEdhamAththavamum"- sarva pApEbhyO mOkshayisyAmi
"Ethu andru enpAr Ar"- mAsucha:
To Be Continued)
Azhvar emperumAnAr Jeeyer thiruvadigalE sharaNam
Adiyen ramanuja dAsee
Sumithra Varadarajan
[Non-text portions of this message have been removed]
Yahoo! Groups Links
<*> To visit your group on the web, go to:
http://groups.yahoo.com/group/Oppiliappan/
<*> To unsubscribe from this group, send an email to:
Oppiliappan-unsubscribe@xxxxxxxxxxxxxxx
<*> Your use of Yahoo! Groups is subject to:
http://docs.yahoo.com/info/terms/
|
Home Page
http://www.ibiblio.org/sripedia |
oppiliappan-subscribe@yahoogroups.com To subscribe to the list |