I am attempting to switch over to a Koine (1st-2nd c. CE) pronunciation of Koine Greek from a restored Classical scheme. I've used Buth's books in the past so the pronunciation is not entirely new for me. Here's my attempt at reading Philemon from the SBLGNT:
https://archive.org/details/philemon_201912
My pronunciation differs from Randall Buth's scheme in that I maintain the spiritus asper, hard δ, and aspirated stops, since these were maintained (except the spiritus asper in some places) in the first century. It's still a work in progress, but it helps that my first language (Korean) has aspirated and non-aspirated forms of all consonants. The hardest sound for me to pronounce consistently is η. In unstressed syllables I find it really hard to distinguish it from ε, and I don't want to pronounce it as a dipthong ("ei") as in Erasmian. Coincidentally, Korean also has two vowels that parallel ε (ㅐ) and η (ㅔ), but native Korean speakers can hardly tell the difference anymore. I know that in modern French the distinction between [e] and [ε] is also disappearing, especially in unstressed syllables. Maybe that was the case in Koine Greek in unstressed syllables?
Let me know if you have any feedback.
Audio of Philemon in Koine
Re: Audio of Philemon in Koine
Mark, That is a wonderful reading of Philemon.
Your fluency and accuracy is great. Very easy to listen to and understand.
I think my African students wouldn't have any problem distinguishing between THETA as an aspirated T and TAU as unaspirated. For those of us (English 1st language) who did not grow up with aspirated/unaspirated making any difference in meaning, it would be a bit harder to pick up purely from listening. But since we all listen and read the text, and since the combinations are so familiar, T-aspirated Θεός is not hard to understand.
I like the choice to do rough breathing marks.
Your OMICRON-IOTA and UPSILON sound like iota to me, but that's perfectly okay.
What will you record for us next?
Your fluency and accuracy is great. Very easy to listen to and understand.
I think my African students wouldn't have any problem distinguishing between THETA as an aspirated T and TAU as unaspirated. For those of us (English 1st language) who did not grow up with aspirated/unaspirated making any difference in meaning, it would be a bit harder to pick up purely from listening. But since we all listen and read the text, and since the combinations are so familiar, T-aspirated Θεός is not hard to understand.
I like the choice to do rough breathing marks.
Your OMICRON-IOTA and UPSILON sound like iota to me, but that's perfectly okay.
What will you record for us next?
Paul D. Nitz - Lilongwe Malawi
-
- Posts: 3353
- Joined: May 11th, 2011, 10:51 am
- Location: Melbourne
- Contact:
Re: Audio of Philemon in Koine
Fascinating to hear a text with aspirated/non-aspirated consonants like that. Thanks for sharing a fluent performance. Given the differences with Buth, I'd call what you're doing "early Koine" and Buth "late Koine."Mark Jeong wrote: ↑December 14th, 2019, 11:29 pm My pronunciation differs from Randall Buth's scheme in that I maintain the spiritus asper, hard δ, and aspirated stops, since these were maintained (except the spiritus asper in some places) in the first century. It's still a work in progress, but it helps that my first language (Korean) has aspirated and non-aspirated forms of all consonants.
Stephen C. Carlson, Ph.D.
Melbourne, Australia
Melbourne, Australia
-
- Posts: 14
- Joined: February 6th, 2014, 3:25 pm
Re: Audio of Philemon in Koine
Thanks for the feedback! I may try Philippians next.