pronouncing κηρύξω
pronouncing κηρύξω
Hi:
Is there an "s" sound in κηρύξω? Is it pronounced "kay reik so"?
I would have thought it would be pronounced "kay reik o" (i.e. no "s" sound on the third syllable).
Another question I have on κηρύξω is how the word is broken up - I would have thought one would break it up as
κη ρύ ξω (consonant-vowel consonant-vowel consonant-vowel)
but it seems the ξ is part of the second syllable.
I'm sure that the ξ is coming from γσ has something to do with why I'm hearing an "s" on the last syllable.
Glenn
Is there an "s" sound in κηρύξω? Is it pronounced "kay reik so"?
I would have thought it would be pronounced "kay reik o" (i.e. no "s" sound on the third syllable).
Another question I have on κηρύξω is how the word is broken up - I would have thought one would break it up as
κη ρύ ξω (consonant-vowel consonant-vowel consonant-vowel)
but it seems the ξ is part of the second syllable.
I'm sure that the ξ is coming from γσ has something to do with why I'm hearing an "s" on the last syllable.
Glenn
-
- Posts: 3352
- Joined: May 11th, 2011, 10:51 am
- Location: Melbourne
- Contact:
Re: pronouncing κηρύξω
This letter is a compound letter, ξ = κ + σ. So the s-sound is definitely there. The word is divided as you had it: κη-ρύ-ξω.
Stephen C. Carlson, Ph.D.
Melbourne, Australia
Melbourne, Australia
Re: pronouncing κηρύξω
Thanxs for the info Stephen.
So it almost seems like the syllabification of the word has the "original" letters:
κηρύξω is the future tense: κηρύγ + σ + ω (γ + σ => ξ), but when you syllabify you break it down as
κη-ρύγ-σω (I'm pretty sure the consonant cluster γσ cannot be pronounced together which is why the γ goes with the 2nd syllable???)
So it almost seems like the syllabification of the word has the "original" letters:
κηρύξω is the future tense: κηρύγ + σ + ω (γ + σ => ξ), but when you syllabify you break it down as
κη-ρύγ-σω (I'm pretty sure the consonant cluster γσ cannot be pronounced together which is why the γ goes with the 2nd syllable???)
-
- Posts: 711
- Joined: May 5th, 2011, 9:21 pm
- Location: Burnsville, MN, USA
- Contact:
Re: pronouncing κηρύξω
The sound γ loses its voicing before ς = [ks] = ξ, as in fox, box, etc. ξ is a consonant cluster that can begin a word, so it falls under item b below. See http://perseus.uchicago.edu/cgi-bin/phi ... Monographs section §140.
Here are Smyth's rules:
In pronouncing Greek words and in writing (at the end of the line) the rules commonly observed are these:
a. A single consonant standing between two vowels in one word belongs with the second vowel: ἄ-γω, σο-φί-ζω.
b. Any group of consonants that can begin a word, and a group formed by a stop with μ or ν, and by μν, belongs with the second vowel: τύ-πτω, ὄ-γδοος, ἄ-στρον, ἔ-χθος; πρᾶ-γμα, ἔ-θνος, λί-μνη.
c. A group of consonants that cannot begin a word is divided between two syllables: ἄν-θος, ἐλ-πίς, ἔρ-γμα. Doubled consonants are divided: θάλατ-τα.
d. Compounds divide at the point of union: εἰς-φέρω, προς-φέρω; ἀν-άγω, εἰσάγω, συν-έχω. (But the ancients often wrote ἀ-νάγω, εἰ-σάγω, προ-σελθεῖν, ἐ-ξάγω, δυ-σάρεστος.)
e. ς, when followed by one or more consonants, is either attached to the preceding vowel (ἄ-ρις-τος), or, with the consonant, begins the following syllable (ἄ-ρι-στος). (The ancients were not consistent, and there is evidence for the pronunciation ἄ-ρις-στος.)
f. The ancients divided ἐκ τούτου as ἐ-κ τού-του. This practice is now abandoned.
Here are Smyth's rules:
In pronouncing Greek words and in writing (at the end of the line) the rules commonly observed are these:
a. A single consonant standing between two vowels in one word belongs with the second vowel: ἄ-γω, σο-φί-ζω.
b. Any group of consonants that can begin a word, and a group formed by a stop with μ or ν, and by μν, belongs with the second vowel: τύ-πτω, ὄ-γδοος, ἄ-στρον, ἔ-χθος; πρᾶ-γμα, ἔ-θνος, λί-μνη.
c. A group of consonants that cannot begin a word is divided between two syllables: ἄν-θος, ἐλ-πίς, ἔρ-γμα. Doubled consonants are divided: θάλατ-τα.
d. Compounds divide at the point of union: εἰς-φέρω, προς-φέρω; ἀν-άγω, εἰσάγω, συν-έχω. (But the ancients often wrote ἀ-νάγω, εἰ-σάγω, προ-σελθεῖν, ἐ-ξάγω, δυ-σάρεστος.)
e. ς, when followed by one or more consonants, is either attached to the preceding vowel (ἄ-ρις-τος), or, with the consonant, begins the following syllable (ἄ-ρι-στος). (The ancients were not consistent, and there is evidence for the pronunciation ἄ-ρις-στος.)
f. The ancients divided ἐκ τούτου as ἐ-κ τού-του. This practice is now abandoned.
-
- Posts: 3352
- Joined: May 11th, 2011, 10:51 am
- Location: Melbourne
- Contact:
Re: pronouncing κηρύξω
OK, I've got to clarify a couple points. There's no original gamma in κηρύσσω. It was originally *κηρύκ-ι-ω, with a consonantal iota present-stem affix. The future is *κηρύκ-σ-ω > κηρύξω. (The gamma in κήρυγμα is due to a voicing of the original κ next to the voiced μ.)GlennDean wrote:So it almost seems like the syllabification of the word has the "original" letters:
κηρύξω is the future tense: κηρύγ + σ + ω (γ + σ => ξ), but when you syllabify you break it down as
κη-ρύγ-σω (I'm pretty sure the consonant cluster γσ cannot be pronounced together which is why the γ goes with the 2nd syllable???)
As for syllabification, a rule of thumb is that Greek won't break up consonant clusters if they can begin a word (see rule b that Louis quoted). Since ξ can begin a word, a syllable can begin with ξ.
Stephen C. Carlson, Ph.D.
Melbourne, Australia
Melbourne, Australia
Re: pronouncing κηρύξω
I definitely have trouble with ξ.
For example how about λέξεις. According to Smyth's rules (which pretty much agrees with the rules Mounce lists on p.17 of Basics of Biblical Greek (Ed 2) ), we would break that into
λέ-ξεις
but yet when I hear the word it sounds like the pronunciation is "lex-eis" (i.e. the ξ is with the first syllable).
Another example I'm working on is ὤρυξας (which is very similar to κηρύξω in that the ξ is coming from a square-of-stop and a σ).
For example how about λέξεις. According to Smyth's rules (which pretty much agrees with the rules Mounce lists on p.17 of Basics of Biblical Greek (Ed 2) ), we would break that into
λέ-ξεις
but yet when I hear the word it sounds like the pronunciation is "lex-eis" (i.e. the ξ is with the first syllable).
Another example I'm working on is ὤρυξας (which is very similar to κηρύξω in that the ξ is coming from a square-of-stop and a σ).
Re: pronouncing κηρύξω
The question is 'who are you listening to?'. We all tend to pronounce Greek in a way influenced by our first language. If you listen to Modern Greeks pronouncing Greek, λέ-ξεις and κη-ρύ-ξω is exactly how they pronounce it. I am not sure where you got "kay reik so" for κηρύξω, unless by 'reik' you mean 'reek'. In Classical and Koiné Greek 'υ' was pronounces as German ü or french 'u' in 'tu', and in Modern Greek as 'ee'.
Re: pronouncing κηρύξω
I unfortunately don't speak German nor French - my perspective is from an English background. I'm getting "kay reik so" as if writing down what I'm hearing as if it were an English word (so the approximation is probably not so good).klriley wrote:The question is 'who are you listening to?'. We all tend to pronounce Greek in a way influenced by our first language. If you listen to Modern Greeks pronouncing Greek, λέ-ξεις and κη-ρύ-ξω is exactly how they pronounce it. I am not sure where you got "kay reik so" for κηρύξω, unless by 'reik' you mean 'reek'. In Classical and Koiné Greek 'υ' was pronounces as German ü or french 'u' in 'tu', and in Modern Greek as 'ee'.
I'm going thru the "Living Koine Greek" books by Dr. Buth - if anyone else has the books I'm getting these words from
κηρύξω - Book 2A, μάθημα β, track 8
λέξεις - Book 2A, μάθημα ά, track 23
ὤρυξας - Book 2A, μάθημα ά, track 25
Glenn
-
- Posts: 4168
- Joined: May 5th, 2011, 5:34 pm
- Location: Durham, NC
- Contact:
Re: pronouncing κηρύξω
Make your tongue say "ee", and make your lips say "oo".GlennDean wrote:I unfortunately don't speak German nor French - my perspective is from an English background. I'm getting "kay reik so" as if writing down what I'm hearing as if it were an English word (so the approximation is probably not so good).
See if this video helps.
ἐξίσταντο δὲ πάντες καὶ διηποροῦντο, ἄλλος πρὸς ἄλλον λέγοντες, τί θέλει τοῦτο εἶναι;
http://jonathanrobie.biblicalhumanities.org/
http://jonathanrobie.biblicalhumanities.org/
Re: pronouncing κηρύξω
Thanxs - that does help!Jonathan Robie wrote:Make your tongue say "ee", and make your lips say "oo".
See if this video helps.