Home News & Events Action Alert: Stop factory farming and support sustainable livestock production

Sustainable Farming Connection
Where farmers find and share information.

Action Alert, Issued: 10/14/98

Stop factory farming and support sustainable livestock production

Comments needed on the Draft Unified National Strategy For Animal Feeding Operations (AFOs)

The USDA and EPA are taking public comments on a "Draft Unified National Strategy For Animal Feeding Operations (AFOs)." This Draft Strategy is the overall blueprint for dealing with surface water pollution from all AFOs, including large-scale, confined animal factory farms with more than 1,000 animal units. Both USDA and EPA acknowledge in the Draft Strategy that:
  • factory farm operations are a source of significant surface and ground water pollution problems and risks

  • currently about 10,000 of these large-scale, factory farms are operating without permits required under the Clean Water Act
Many animal feeding operations pose unacceptable risks to family farms, the environment, the health of rural communities and to the water resources upon which both rural and urban communities depend.

What you can do:
  1. Submit individual comments on the Draft Strategy. See Details Below. The Draft Strategy is available on the Web at http://www.epa.gov/cleanwater/afo/ and in the Federal Register, Vol. 63 at pp.50192-50209 (September 21, 1998). Mail Comments to Denise C. Coleman, Program Analyst, Natural Resources Conservation Service, ATTN: AFO, Box 2890, Washington, D.C. 20013-2890. Comments must be received by January 19, 1999.

  2. Go to the Public Hearings (called "Listening Sessions") in Your Region. Check the website for the Clean Water Network http://www.cwn.org and click on "What's New". The Clean Water Network will post the times and places for the listening sessions as soon as they are available. You can also contact the National Campaign for Sustainable Agriculture for information on the listening sessions. Email: campaign@magiccarpet.com

  3. Contact your local media, newspapers, radio, television, etc. and let them know of your concerns about factory farms and the health and well-being of rural communities. Provide them with the Campaign information Fact Sheets packet on Factory Farms and the Draft Strategy, available November 1, 1998, or refer them to the National Campaign for Sustainable Agriculture for more information.
What needs changing in the draft strategy
  • Recommend Sustainable Alternatives to Factory Farms:

    Many large-scale factory farms handle massive amounts of animal waste with primitive, open-air cesspool "lagoons" and sprayfields that contaminate groundwater, streams, and the air. In many regions, these factory farms are often crowded together on small land bases and animal waste is dumped on the land at rates far exceeding those recommended as sound practice for agricultural production. People in neighboring communities around the nation are vigorously protesting the disruption to their lives and health from the stench and air pollution and the fouling of drinking water and recreational water resources caused by these factory farms.

    The Draft Strategy acknowledges the roots of factory farming pollution problems: the decoupling of animal production from feed production and the concentration of large amounts of manure and wastewater on farms and in watersheds. Yet, the Draft Strategy assumes, erroneously, that large-scale factory farming is both inevitable and potentially sustainable, and recommends the expenditure of large amounts of public funds for technical assistance and cost-share money to encourage and subsidize factory farms and for a regulatory system that will attempt to bandage over some of the excesses of a deeply flawed production system.

    Economic and environmentally-sound sustainable alternatives exist to large-scale factory farms. The Draft Strategy should recommend that these existing, truly sustainable livestock production practices be encouraged as alternatives to factory farms.

  • Require Individual Clean Water Act Permits, Instead of Rubber-Stamping General Permits or Watershed Permits

    The Draft Strategy acknowledges that current regulations and standards for dealing with factory farm pollution are inadequate, that a backlog of almost 10,000 operations need Clean Water Act permits, and that many of these facilities are currently the source of significant water pollution problems. The Draft Strategy proposes, however, that most existing operations be regulated under a general permit process, which does not give neighboring communities notice or an opportunity to review and comment before the permit is granted. Most of these permits will be issued in advance of proposed regulatory amendment and new requirements for nutrient management plans, providing factory farms with rubber-stamp approval to continue using large-scale, liquid manure storage facilities and land application sprayfields. Proposed watershed permits may be even more inadequate, allowing for a blanket approval of all factory farms packed into a single watershed without adequate analysis of the cumulative impacts on the watershed or sufficient public participation in the permitting process.

    The Draft Strategy should be revised to require that existing large-scale, liquid manure handling systems be phased out and these systems be prohibited in any permit for new or expanding operations. In addition, a sound Strategy should impose a moratorium on new or expanding factory farms, until environmental impacts are assessed and adequate regulatory measures are adopted for dealing with these impacts.

  • Land Application of Animal Waste Should be Based on Sound Standards for Water Quality Protection

    The Draft Strategy represents a big step forward in that both USDA and EPA now acknowledge that land application of animal waste from factory farms should be regulated. The Draft Strategy, however, depends heavily on USDA Natural Resources Conservation Service (NRCS) standards as the basis for Clean Water Act permits for factory farms, including the standards for land application of animal waste. These NRCS standards, however, may vary greatly from county to county and are in need of significant revision and national guidance from USDA on their application. Although the Draft Strategy calls for Comprehensive Nutrient Management Plans for factory farms with permits, the Draft Strategy provides little detail as to what standards will actually govern the content of these plans

    The Draft Strategy should clarify that the standards for Comprehensive Nutrient Management Plans will include both nitrogen and phosphorus limitations, based on water quality protection, for land application of factory farm animal waste. The Draft Strategy should also clarify the relationship between EPA's effluent guidelines for land applied animal waste and the NRCS technical standards for nutrient management. All permitted facilities should have a Comprehensive Nutrient Management Plan, which the public can review before the permit is approved and whose implementation is a fully enforceable condition of the permit.

  • Impose Legal Liability and Financial Responsibility for Factory Farm Pollution on Vertical Integrators

    Vertical integrators are the processing companies, which often own the animals raised on factory farms and dictate operating conditions on the factory farms. The vertical integrators are the fat cats in the factory farm system, but the Draft Strategy allows vertical integrators to dodge any financial or legal responsibility for a factory farm system that has made them billions of dollars in profits. The entire financial burden for dealing with factory farm pollution in the integrated systems falls on contract farmers and the taxpayers. This is a double blow for independent livestock producers who must compete with companies that can dodge financial responsibility for the problems they cause and who will also pay taxes to subsidize the costs of cleaning up the mess left by the factory farm production system.

    The Draft Strategy should require that vertical integrators who own the animals in factory farms and/or dictate the conditions for operation of factory farms be legally liable and financially responsible for factory farm pollution.
Action Alert issued by:

National Campaign for Sustainable Agriculture
P.O. Box 396
Pine Bush, NY 12566
Phone: 914-744-8448
Fax: 914-74-8477
campaign@magiccarpet.com

Top of Page

Home News & Events Action Alert:


©1998 Committee for Sustainable Farm Publishing

Please read about our usage permission policy and disclaimer.

Send comments, suggestions and questions to the site author:
Craig Cramer cdcramer@clarityconnect.com

Coded using HoTMetaL Pro 3.0. Best viewed in Netscape 3.0 or later.
Please see our credits page for more information.

http://sunsite.unc.edu/farming-connection/news/actalert/981017.htm